« The Conversion | The Curse is Over »


The Great Debate - 1975 Reds Vs. 1984 Tigers - Catcher
October 21st, 2004 | Blade

We’ll start with an easy one.

Johnny Bench is listed as the second best catcher of all time in Bill James Historical Baseball Abstract. The fourteen time all-star and two time Most Valuable Player truly had an astounding career. Not only did he hit 389 career homeruns, and drive in 1,376 runs, but he also racked up ten gold gloves.

But this isn’t a debate about careers. How did Johnny Bench do in 1975 compared to Lance Parrish in 1984? Let’s take a look at some of Bench’s statistics.

Runs - 83
Homeruns - 28
RBIs - 110
Average - .283
OBP - .359
Slg. - .519
OPS+ - 140
Runs Created - 99
Batting Runs Above Replacement - 53
Field Runs Above Replacement - 47
Equalized Average - .308
Wins Above Replacement Player - 11.0

The only thing that prevents a complete sweep is Lance Parrish’s five extra homeruns. But that’s not nearly enough to make up the difference. Johnny Bench didn’t finish fourth in the MVP voting for nothing.

This one was a fat pitch waiting to get hit out of the park. Johnny Bench wins hands down.

Score Card - 1975 Reds 1, 1984 Tigers 0

And don’t forget to help us out with our little fund raiser. It might take the simulation to convince Brian who’s better.

And you can read Brian’s response over at Tigerblog. He took his beating like a man.



Comments are closed.

Reds Resources
Baseball Historians
Minor League Blogs
Sportsbook
GetMeIn.com
SEARCH CUTTING EDGE


Built by
Grousehouse Media

Hosted by
Dreamhost

RSS 2.0
SEND EMAIL
Your email:

Subject:

Message:

REDS SITES

OTHER BASEBALL
HISTORICAL BASEBALL SITES




Archives by Month
Archives by Category
Meta
Powered by
WordPress
Coast to Coast Tickets

Find hot event tickets such as Cincinnati Reds baseball tickets and Cincinnati Bengals football tickets at CTC. We carry MLB Baseball tickets including premium Astros tickets, St Louis Cardinals tickets and World Series tickets as well as Cincinnati event tickets such as concert tickets. We have Bengals Paul Brown Stadium tickets, Ravens tickets at M&T Bank Stadium, Steelers football games, Browns tickets for sale and college sports tickets including Ohio State Buckeyes tickets and Michigan Wolverines tickets.
***
Sports Tickets
***
Vivid Seats
Ticket Broker
Boston Red Sox Tickets
Orioles Tickets
NY Yankees Tickets
Buffett Tickets
Chicago Cubs Tickets
Bears Tickets
Broadway Tickets
Chicago Bears Tickets
Spamalot Tickets
Madonna Tickets
Baseball Tickets
Ticket Broker
Red Sox Tickets
Yankees Tickets
Cubs Tickets
Concert Tickets
***
Ticketbroker.com
Ticket Brokers is your online marketplace for Red Sox Tickets, Cubs Tickets, White Sox Tickets, NBA All Star Game Tickets, Bears Tickets, Pearl Jam Tickets, Radiohead Tickets, Metallica Tickets and AC/DC Tickets.
***
Frontrowusa.com
Front Row USA has premier sports tickets for your favorite teams - Red Sox Tickets, Marlins Tickets, Orioles Tickets, Phillies Tickets, Tampa Bay Rays Tickets, Dolphins Tickets and Jets Tickets. We also have front row Tina Turner Tickets and Madonna Tickets.
***
RazorGator.com
Tickets to all Cincinnati Sports and Ohio sports including Cincinnati Reds tickets, Bengals tickets, and Ohio State Buckeyes tickets. Tigers tickets, Mets tickets, World Series tickets, and other hard to get Baseball Tickets.
***
TicketLiquidator.com
We have top Cincinnati Reds tickets, plus a loaded NFL schedule. Get great views with our Indianapolis Colts tickets, New England Patriots tickets, Denver Broncos tickets, Philadelphia Eagles tickets, Dallas Cowboys tickets, Pittsburgh Steelers tickets, Kansas City Chiefs, Atlanta Falcons tickets, Jacksonville Jaguars tickets, and North Carolina State Wolfpack tickets.
***
Seatwave - Buy or Sell
Ricky Hatton Tickets Getafe tickets The Ashes tickets World Darts Championships tickets Juventus tickets AC Milan tickets Joe Calzaghe tickets Black Crowes tickets Def Leppard tickets New York Giants tickets
***
Sponsored by BetUS Sportsbook
BetUS Sportsbook is your source for MLB Baseball betting. Check out BetUS for MLB odds and baseball betting lines.
***
SoldoutEntertainments
Sold Out Entertainments Football Tickets Cricket Tickets Cricket World Cup Tickets Golf Tickets Ryder Cup Tickets Rugby Tickets 2007 Rugby World Cup Tickets Tennis Tickets Wimbledon Tickets Music Festival Tickets
***
Best Show Tickets Las Vegas
Cheapest MLB Tickets
Cincinnati Reds Tickets
World Series Tickets
Cardinals Tickets
Boston Red Sox Tickets
New York Yankees
Orioles Tickets
Packers Tickets
Super Bowl Tickets
New England Patriots Tickets
Learn about buying tickets online
***
StubHub.com
Cincinnati Reds Tickets
Detroit Tigers Tickets
New York Mets Tickets
San Diego Padres Tickets
Phillies Tickets
Astros Tickets
San Francisco Giants Tickets
Oakland A's Tickets
***
TicketLiquidator.com
Baseball Tickets
***
Tickco.com
Choose TickCo.com for your premium Cincinnati Reds tickets, Cincinnati Bengals tickets and all other Cincinnati event tickets. See your Reds on the road with Indians tickets, Twins tickets, Detroit Tigers tickets, Atlanta Braves tickets, Mets tickets, Boston Red Sox tickets, Chicago Cubs tickets, Houston Astros tickets and more.
***
Great Seats
Detroit Tigers Tickets Detroit Lions Tickets Detroit Pistons Tickets Michigan 400 Tickets. We provide Baltimor e Orioles Tickets, Washi ngton Nationals Tickets, and Houston Astros Tickets, St Louis Cardinals, and MLB All Star Tickets at GreatSeats.com.
***
Best Show Tickets Las Vegas
Cheapest MLB Tickets
Cincinnati Reds Tickets
World Series Tickets
Cardinals Tickets
Boston Red Sox Tickets
New York Yankees
Orioles Tickets
Packers Tickets
Super Bowl Tickets
New England Patriots Tickets
***
***
Chicago Gigs
Reds Tickets
Cubs Tickets
White Sox Tickets
Bengals Tickets
Bears Tickets
***
Online Seats
Baseball Tickets
Cincinnati Reds Tickets
Great American Ball Park Tickets
Football Tickets
Cincinnati Bengals Tickets
***
Sold Out Event Tickets
Cricket Tickets, AC Milan Tickets, Sports Tickets, Theatre Tickets, Sound of Music Tickets, Dirty Dancing Tickets, Billy Elliot Tickets, Mary Poppins Tickets, Lion King Tickets, Cheap Theatre Tickets
1st 4 Football Tickets
Football Tickets
Click to advertise